Subscribe
Notify of
guest

277 Comments
newest
oldest most voted

NorseTikiBar
NorseTikiBar (@guest_1933335)
October 16, 2024 15:55

P1 Fail DP:
6/3/2024 account approve, created
6/13/2024 $501 Schwab push
6/18/2024 $501 Schwab push
7/8/2024 $501 Schwab push
8/2/2024 $501 Schwab push
9/12/2024 $501 Schwab push
10/16/2024 posting in defeat

Jake
Jake (@guest_1933157)
October 16, 2024 09:26

Looks like this deal is active again

Eric 🔗
Eric 🔗 (@guest_1930270)
October 11, 2024 08:14

Johnz,

Another online bill that had been working for Andrews now shows as “Withdrawal Bill Payment” this month, like Fios does. Andrews is making it harder and harder to qualify for the 6% rate. Have you noticed anything similar?

Johnz
Johnz (@guest_1930274)
October 11, 2024 08:34

Eric 🔗 Yes. Since August I’ve used Cash app loads which coded as Withdrawal Debit Card. Except just once in August Cash app load coded as Withdrawal ACH Cash App. So now I periodically review the Cash app coding to catch any stray ACH withdrawals, but there haven’t been any so far.

Eric 🔗
Eric 🔗 (@guest_1930437)
October 11, 2024 12:37

Did you miss out on the 6% rate in August because of that 1 hiccup or did you catch it in time?

Johnz
Johnz (@guest_1930463)
October 11, 2024 13:04

Got the 6%, my first cash app load was the ACH hiccup and being my first I looked and was shocked to see it coded as ACH. My next 45 loads for Aug-Oct coded Withdrawal Debit Card.

Eric 🔗
Eric 🔗 (@guest_1930485)
October 11, 2024 13:23

How insane is it that they consider a Cash App load as a QDP but they don’t consider paying Fios or some other bills as a QDP?

MoreSun
MoreSun (@guest_1918494)
September 24, 2024 14:33

5/16 open
5/30, 6/30, 7/30, 8/30 work DDs $500
9/23 no bonus, sent SM
9/24 SM replied they reviewed my account and posted the bonus

Wayne
Wayne (@guest_1903310)
September 1, 2024 09:44

This is the first month after my bonus posted and I did not receive the 6% interest rate. I met the criteria. Did this happen to anyone else?

Eric
Eric (@guest_1903314)
September 1, 2024 09:50

Did you confirm that all 15 debit purchases showed up as “Withdrawal Debit Card”. If any did not, that’s probably why you didn’t receive the 6% rate.

Eric
Eric (@guest_1903317)
September 1, 2024 09:51

Wayne,

BTW, “Withdrawal POS” is also acceptable.

Wayne
Wayne (@guest_1903319)
September 1, 2024 09:54

All 16 say either “Withdrawal Debit card (11) or Withdrawal bill payment (5).

Eric
Eric (@guest_1903320)
September 1, 2024 09:55

Unfortunately, “Withdrawal Bill Payment” does not count. You must have missed the discussion that Johnz and I had about this 1 or 2 months ago in this post.

Wayne
Wayne (@guest_1903323)
September 1, 2024 09:58

I did miss it. Unfortunately P2 passed away a few months back and I have missed numerous things. Eric 🔗 thank you for clarifying.

Eric
Eric (@guest_1903333)
September 1, 2024 10:20

I am very sorry for your loss.

Wayne
Wayne (@guest_1903334)
September 1, 2024 10:23

Thank you very much.

Davis
Davis (@guest_1903356)
September 1, 2024 11:32

Same with me. All my normal Paypal 1 cents before this month were Recurring Withdrawal Debit Card but this month they were Recurring Withdrawal Bill Payment, so Andrews said I did 0. I’ll try again in September with Paypal and hope it will be resolved. OnPath did not have any issue with this method.

Davis
Davis (@guest_1903999)
September 2, 2024 17:36

I think Paypal 1 cent subscriptions are dead for this option. The two transactions in September still have bill payment on them.

Wayne
Wayne (@guest_1894400)
August 17, 2024 04:37

Opened in May w/$25,000 for mainly 6% interest rate
Did an assortment of 15 debit card transactions for $1.00+each month, plus used Wise for DD
$150 bonus posted today.

Jennifer ✝️🦁🕊️🙏🐘
Jennifer ✝️🦁🕊️🙏🐘 (@guest_1884591)
July 30, 2024 12:16

Hey, can someone check their account and let me know if the monthly interest posted today, or if it doesn’t post till tonight’s processing? I am not sure if I qualified for my interest for the month because my 15th transaction posted on the 29th which is the cutoff day , so I don’t know if that means it had to post *before* the 29th, or *on* the 29th. Thanks, I appreciate it.

Wayne
Wayne (@guest_1884755)
July 30, 2024 16:51

Hasn’t posted yet.

Jennifer ✝️🦁🕊️🙏🐘
Jennifer ✝️🦁🕊️🙏🐘 (@guest_1884764)
July 30, 2024 17:05

Thanks for confirming, I really appreciate it 🙂👍

Johnz
Johnz (@guest_1884937)
July 30, 2024 20:58

Jennifer, the interest posts the last night of the calendar month, the end of the statement cycle. July’s ‘cutoff day’ is the 30th.. Andrews explains it in https://www.andrewsfcu.org/getmedia/37153faf-31ff-4f79-a5dc-b77d008a56aa/Kasasa-Cycle-Dates-December-2023.pdf

Jennifer ✝️🦁🕊️🙏🐘
Jennifer ✝️🦁🕊️🙏🐘 (@guest_1885289)
July 31, 2024 12:50

So I just checked, and my interest didn’t post yet. Did everyone get theirs last night, or does it post tonight?

Johnz
Johnz (@guest_1885301)
July 31, 2024 13:04

tonight

Jennifer ✝️🦁🕊️🙏🐘
Jennifer ✝️🦁🕊️🙏🐘 (@guest_1885344)
July 31, 2024 14:07

Thanks johnz, I was thinking it would post tonight as well, but before I saw your other comment regarding the cycle ending in the 30th this month(meing my 15th transaction posted on the 29th made it in time), i called the branch and asked if this month’s interest already posted, because I didn’t receive mine yet, she said yes, interest posted today.

So I was really distraught over it, but rather than keep asking questions, I just figured she probably was wrong, and that it should post tonight, but I knew someone on here would know for sure. I appreciate you answering, I feel better now, because there’s no reason I shouldn’t receive my interest for july.

Jennifer ✝️🦁🕊️🙏🐘
Jennifer ✝️🦁🕊️🙏🐘 (@guest_1885340)
July 31, 2024 14:02

Thanks, I saved this. That’s great that it’s the 30th for this month, my last transaction posted the 29th.

Bertha
Bertha (@guest_1884584)
July 30, 2024 11:58

$150 bonus posted today
I think it’s Wise that’s counted as DD.
3/21 Kasasa Cash Ck account opened
3/26, 4/15, 5/17, 6/21 Fidelity push in $500.10 each time
5/15, 5/29 Real DD $500
5/15, 6/25, 7/16 Wise push in $500.61 *I put “Payroll” in memo line.
7/30 $150 bonus posted as “Deposit GET $150 PROMO” 
Thanks DoC and all helpful DPs here!

Brown Guy Churning
Brown Guy Churning (@guest_1861611)
June 19, 2024 11:45

Transferred from Fidelity per the DPs but saying it was not qualifying DD and are denying the SUB.

ShawntheShawn👈🏾
ShawntheShawn👈🏾 (@guest_1861620)
June 19, 2024 12:11
Jack
Jack (@guest_1861744)
June 19, 2024 16:18

Unfortunately you’re not a qualifying churner because you call the bank. Don’t call the bank Brown Guy Churning

Brown Guy Churning
Brown Guy Churning (@guest_1861750)
June 19, 2024 16:22

Messaged them did not call. Also how else would I fight them?

Wayne
Wayne (@guest_1861862)
June 19, 2024 21:00

Can fight with fake DD! It’s hit or miss.

Wayne
Wayne (@guest_1866913)
June 30, 2024 08:09

Just realized I meant to say you “can’t” fight fake DD’s.

Jack
Jack (@guest_1861885)
June 19, 2024 21:28

Shawn, how can this Brown University Guy go about this? ShawntheShawn👈🏾

ShawntheShawn👈🏾
ShawntheShawn👈🏾 (@guest_1861931)
June 19, 2024 22:27

Well, this promotion has clearly defined what qualifying direct deposits are and what do not count. If it were me, I would just give Andrews the maximum allowed time for payout per the terms (maybe plus one to three more weeks) to see if the bonus posts automatically. Meanwhile I would read others’ DPs in this post to see which fake DD works and which does not, as this shall help me decide whether I should wait a bit longer or not. Actually there are already DPs that Fidelity does not work for triggering the bonus. If I do not get paid, I would just take the loss and move on.
The whole point of the “PSA: Don’t Call The Bank” post is to make every bank promotion and the churning game sustain longer for the community.

Jack
Jack (@guest_1862200)
June 20, 2024 11:33

Shawn has some tips for you
Brown Guy Churning Brown Guy Churning

RobertL
RobertL (@guest_1885350)
July 31, 2024 14:29

If you’re using a fake DD, how could you fight with them? Churner never call the bank.

Eric 🔗
Eric 🔗 (@guest_1886347)
August 1, 2024 18:40

RobertL,

You might be surprised to learn that a lot of churners “call the bank”. Dirk is a good example of someone that does it all of the time.

RobertL
RobertL (@guest_1886366)
August 1, 2024 18:59

LOL, “all of the time”, that’s crazy, jumping on the fire

Peter
Peter (@guest_1861150)
June 18, 2024 11:22

Is this churnable? If so, How often? I see 6 months but not so clear in the terms. Thanks in advance.

ShawntheShawn👈🏾
ShawntheShawn👈🏾 (@guest_1861166)
June 18, 2024 11:42

This was in the terms for the promotion that has already ended: Previous memberships that were closed within 180 days prior to promo are not eligible for this offer.