Subscribe
Notify of
guest

97 Comments
newest
oldest most voted

Humberto de Richmond.
Humberto de Richmond. (@guest_1897425)
August 22, 2024 12:59

I made two transfers. One was described as “ACH credit / prearranged “ (discover) and the other one “ACH Credfit / acct transfer” (credit union)
What’s the best guess if these count as DD?

Eric 🔗
Eric 🔗 (@guest_1857042)
June 7, 2024 13:28

I decided to take one for the team today (mainly for Jimmy) and tried to open an account in-branch with high Chex stats. I’m not sure exactly what they are currently as I haven’t checked my report in a while.

Anyway, I had no issues at all and the banker opened the account for me with the promo attached. I requested a print out of the promo’s disclosures just in case an issue arises later.

When I got home later, I saw that I received an email alert from OnAlert so my Chex was definitely pulled before opening.

This confirms that Valley, just like NYCB/Flagstar and Blue Foundry before it, is much less Chex-sensitive in-branch than online.

I smartly only applied in-branch for NYCB and Valley while stupidly applied both ways for Blue Foundry (in the same day) and ended up with 2 Chex inquiries for my trouble. You live and you learn. 🙂

Bertrand
Bertrand (@guest_1857047)
June 7, 2024 13:34

This was my experience too back in 2019. Not Chex-sensitive in branch.

Jimmy
Jimmy (@guest_1857376)
June 8, 2024 10:00

Eric Good news your trip to the branch was worth while. I’ll probably have to give it a shot here pretty soon. Are you going to try Fidelity for the DD req’s?

Eric 🔗
Eric 🔗 (@guest_1857378)
June 8, 2024 10:07

I’ll probably try TD 1st but we’ll see.

Mrs. Gee
Mrs. Gee (@guest_1886745)
August 2, 2024 09:08

Eric, what did you end up using and how did that work out? I’ll be taking your advice and opening in-branch.

Eric 🔗
Eric 🔗 (@guest_1887103)
August 2, 2024 18:53

TD and it’s triggered the monthly bonus.

Dan
Dan (@guest_1887835)
August 4, 2024 12:51

Do you mean TD bank or treasury direct?

Eric 🔗
Eric 🔗 (@guest_1888974)
August 6, 2024 18:49

The latter. The acronym that I use for the former is TDB.

Eric 🔗
Eric 🔗 (@guest_1847386)
May 20, 2024 17:23

 William Charles,

The link in this post leads to a “Page not found” message.

Below is the correct link to the current offer.

https://www.valley.com/personal/checking/all-access-rewards-checking?

Jimmy
Jimmy (@guest_1846657)
May 18, 2024 12:57

Declined due to Chex

Christopher Robin
Christopher Robin (@guest_1846826)
May 19, 2024 04:38

Have to apply in branch for this one to avoid Chex sensitivity

Eric 🔗
Eric 🔗 (@guest_1846833)
May 19, 2024 07:03

Jimmy,

See the discussion that Christopher and I had about this in the link below.

https://www.doctorofcredit.com/al-ct-d-c-md-pa-va-wv-fl-nj-ny-and-pa-only-valley-national-bank-240-checking-bonus-20-per-month/#comment-1692697

Christopher Robin,

Can you believe that I still have this account on my To Do List? We had this discussion almost a year ago.

Christopher Robin
Christopher Robin (@guest_1846837)
May 19, 2024 07:10

Eric 🔗,

Nothing wrong with that. Lots of deals out there to do without having to go into a branch. When I did Valley National myself, I worked it in between errands.

Jimmy
Jimmy (@guest_1846851)
May 19, 2024 07:49

That’s funny, I drive by a branch pretty regularly while running errands myself and always wonder if they have any promos. Maybe I should apply in person one of these days. First, I think I should let my Chex cool off a little while. I’ve gone pretty hard lately on new accounts.

Eric 🔗
Eric 🔗 (@guest_1846856)
May 19, 2024 08:01

Christopher Robin does the same or more promos than we do and he was approved so you’re probably worrying for nothing. Let me know how it goes as I am eager to apply also.

Jimmy
Jimmy (@guest_1846861)
May 19, 2024 08:37

24 new account since 3/26 lol. Will let you know if I make it up there one of these days. By the way, you guys know what the story with the clawbacks was? The only way I see this bonus being worthwhile is if I can make a quick Fidelity push and pull for a $20 gain each month.

Christopher Robin
Christopher Robin (@guest_1846889)
May 19, 2024 10:18

I average 2 to 3 Chex inquiries per month. Naturally, this isn’t counting for the bank accounts that didn’t involve Chex. I’m not familiar with any clawbacks.

Jimmy
Jimmy (@guest_1846912)
May 19, 2024 11:23

There’s a comment below eluding to the bank doing clawbacks on people who were sending spoof DDs . I assume it may have been for a previous offer or something.

Eric 🔗
Eric 🔗 (@guest_1846938)
May 19, 2024 12:23

Can you provide the link(s) to these comments? I’d like to check them out before I apply.

Eric 🔗
Eric 🔗 (@guest_1846935)
May 19, 2024 12:20

It was my mistake to compare Jimmy, the king of bank bonuses, with mere mortals like you and me.

Jimmy
Jimmy (@guest_1846940)
May 19, 2024 12:29

Lol Eric you’re too kind.

Eric 🔗
Eric 🔗 (@guest_1846926)
May 19, 2024 12:04

Are you saying that that you applied for 24 accounts in that time frame, you had 24 approvals in that time frame or there are 24 Chex inquiries since that time?

Regardless, that is a lot in a short period of time. I am interested if Valley says anything.

What clawbacks are you referring to?

Jimmy
Jimmy (@guest_1846937)
May 19, 2024 12:23

https://www.doctorofcredit.com/al-ct-d-c-md-pa-va-wv-fl-nj-ny-and-pa-only-valley-national-bank-240-checking-bonus-20-per-month/#comment-1453022

Bill made a comment about people saying they had their bonus clawed back. I haven’t looked into it further than that.

I’ve opened 24 new accounts in that time frame, and been declined for several others. Of course not all made Chex inquiries, but I’m guessing I have at least 15-20 inquiries since the latter part of March.

Eric 🔗
Eric 🔗 (@guest_1846944)
May 19, 2024 12:32

Jimmy,

Are you aware of the below post? If not, you should definitely check it out and keep track of your stats going forward.

https://www.doctorofcredit.com/you-can-now-receive-your-chexsystems-report-online/

Jimmy
Jimmy (@guest_1846950)
May 19, 2024 12:53

Yes Jimmy , I’m aware. I recently pulled my report, it looked like a short novel.

Yeah the claw back is probably not anything to worry about, especially given the nature of the promotion. It won’t take long to find out if there’s an issue.

Eric 🔗
Eric 🔗 (@guest_1846979)
May 19, 2024 14:33

I saw that you tagged yourself by mistake like I’ve done on a few occasions. 🙂

Jimmy
Jimmy (@guest_1847069)
May 19, 2024 19:59

Eric Lmao 🙂 looks like I did tag myself, how funny.

Eric 🔗
Eric 🔗 (@guest_1846942)
May 19, 2024 12:31

Jimmy,

I’m not too worried about that comment as it was pretty much hearsay.

Bill Christopher Robin

Can you both confirm that you have continued to receive your $20 monthly bonus by using a Fidelity transfer?

Christopher Robin
Christopher Robin (@guest_1847017)
May 19, 2024 16:41

Eric ,

I did not use Fidelity transfer. I used real DDs.

Bill
Bill (@guest_1847156)
May 20, 2024 02:18

Yes, I got paid all year for my Fidelity transfers.

Eric 🔗
Eric 🔗 (@guest_1847173)
May 20, 2024 07:23

Jimmy,

I hope that this will calm your fears and you will apply ASAP in-branch. 🙂

Jimmy
Jimmy (@guest_1847205)
May 20, 2024 09:32

Eric

I think it’s more wanting to avoid sitting across from a banker that’s looking at a copy of my Chex report. Can’t you TOFTT and go first? lol

Eric 🔗
Eric 🔗 (@guest_1847302)
May 20, 2024 13:10

I had to look up “TOFTT” as I have never seen that acronym used before. Trust me, I am planning on going at some point. It may or may not before you go.

Jimmy
Jimmy (@guest_1847602)
May 21, 2024 10:55

Eric
Looks like it’s an ongoing deal, or perpetual even, so I figure it can’t hurt to let my inquiries cool off for a little while before I go. That and it’s not really that exciting of an offer, but it’s not terrible either. It reminds me of the Laurel Road promo but without the added $300 for the first month. And Laurel is apparently a lot more strict on DD requirements compared to before.

Eric 🔗
Eric 🔗 (@guest_1847921)
May 21, 2024 21:18

It’s actually more similar to the deal that Investors Bank used to have before they merged with Citizens. I did that offer 3 times.

Bill
Bill (@guest_1692593)
September 13, 2023 12:10

They’re changing their systems (the letter says “a better banking experience for you”, yeah right) and as of 10/10/23, you will need to keep a $99 balance to avoid a $15 monthly charge. I just got my 12th $20 credit this month, so I guess it’s time to close the account.

Not clear if the Rewards account will remain available for new customers, since it seems like they’re changing most of their checking accounts to a single product. The letter does not say anything about rewards other than that you will get a 1099-B.

Eric
Eric (@guest_1692683)
September 13, 2023 13:25

Bill,

What were your Chex stats before you applied?

Bill
Bill (@guest_1692688)
September 13, 2023 13:29

Sorry, I do not pay attention to Chex since I don’t open that many accounts. And I opened the account online.

MisterBill
MisterBill (@guest_1462744)
October 11, 2022 16:42

Was having trouble connecting to Quicken, so I contacted them via secure messaging. Finally had to call and ot some woman who told me that I needed to manually download transactions. Was not happy, but I tried it, and Quicken then asked if I wanted to set up automatic downloads. Turns out that their Quicken name is “Valley – OnlineBanking”, even though Valley National Bank is also listed. They really are incompetent.

M

Bill
Bill (@guest_1453022)
September 26, 2022 17:15

So, in light of the post below saying that people had the bonus clawed back when they did bank transfers instead of true direct deposit, have people been successful getting the $20/mo this time with something other than a true DD?

MisterBill
MisterBill (@guest_1458345)
October 4, 2022 16:27

Update — I did an ACH from Fidelity and got my first $20. Will have to set up a recurring transfer for the same amount (I did not do exactly $750).

Eric
Eric (@guest_1648357)
July 6, 2023 14:44

Have you been using Fidelity for the DD each month and if so, have you been receiving the $20 monthly reward?

Bill
Bill (@guest_1648593)
July 6, 2023 21:23

Yes and yes. Have recurring transfers set up in and out.

Eric
Eric (@guest_1648935)
July 7, 2023 12:01

Are you same person as MisterBill?

MisterBill
MisterBill (@guest_1649093)
July 7, 2023 15:12

Yes, sorry. Was replying from my phone while out of town and obviously did not have the posting info saved in cookies here. I was wondering why my reply went into moderation. Apparently I also mistyped my email address.

Are you doing Fidelity and not getting the $20, or did you not try it?

Eric
Eric (@guest_1649721)
July 8, 2023 17:47

I haven’t applied yet. I applied a couple of years ago and got rejected for Chex. Do you happen to have your Chex stats for when you were approved? Did you apply online or in-branch?

Eric
Eric (@guest_1649723)
July 8, 2023 17:48

Also, do you use Fidelity brokerage or CMA?

Eric
Eric (@guest_1657857)
July 21, 2023 16:12

MisterBill,

I just wanted to make sure that you didn’t miss my 2 replies to you on 7.8.23.

Bill
Bill (@guest_1657881)
July 21, 2023 17:09

I use my brokerage account, but I think it’s irrelevant since the transfer looks the same from both.

Eric
Eric (@guest_1658221)
July 22, 2023 13:40

Bill,

Thank you for answering that question but these are the questions I was more interested in seeing your responses.

“Do you happen to have your Chex stats for when you were approved? Did you apply online or in-branch?”

gordda40
gordda40 (@guest_1753237)
December 7, 2023 08:06

Just signed up to this one as I also have one of their high yield savings account. Just did my first transfer in from Fidelity and waiting to see if it still works. How long was it between time of the “direct deposit” and when you would get the $20.00? It just says it will be within 35 days, but what was your experience?

Christopher Robin
Christopher Robin (@guest_1753274)
December 7, 2023 09:14

gordda40 Over this year, the $20 would typically post between the 2nd and 5th of each month. However, they recently switched over to a new system and I needed to bring the missing $20 for November to their attention and they manually credited it. I haven’t yet received for December (met requirements during November).

gordda40
gordda40 (@guest_1753375)
December 7, 2023 11:41

Thanks! I will have to see what I get in January. Were you using real DD or Fidelity or something else?

Christopher Robin
Christopher Robin (@guest_1753587)
December 7, 2023 15:50

Real DD

Gadget - Bank Bonus Geek
Gadget - Bank Bonus Geek (@guest_1381685)
May 16, 2022 13:44

P2, about 2x Chex hits per month…. Denied. In listed state (VA), but OOF.

“Thank you for your recent application. We’re sorry, but at this time we are unable to open the checking account you applied for. Our decision was based on information we received from the consumer reporting agency listed below.

Credit reporting agency details

Chex Systems, Inc., Attn: Consumer Relations
7805 Hudson Road, Suite 100
Woodbury, MN 55125”

Christopher Robin
Christopher Robin (@guest_1381702)
May 16, 2022 14:10

I was denied in January of this year due to Chex even though I am within footprint (in FL).

I plan to try in branch.

Gadget

Gadget - Bank Bonus Geek
Gadget - Bank Bonus Geek (@guest_1381708)
May 16, 2022 14:19

Yeah, I am not sure why they even list VA as a footprint state… when the nearest branch is in NJ. Anyway, good luck with that. I can’t say I have seen a difference in approval standards in-branch vs online with other banks, you just bypass identity issues.

Bertrand
Bertrand (@guest_1381740)
May 16, 2022 15:06

I was approved in-branch back in 2019 with a pretty full Chex report.

Eric
Eric (@guest_1648348)
July 6, 2023 14:36

What did you use for the DD?

Eric
Eric (@guest_1648347)
July 6, 2023 14:35

Did you end up applying in-branch? If so, were you approved?

Christopher Robin
Christopher Robin (@guest_1692697)
September 13, 2023 13:32

Eric Sorry, I didn’t see this until random chance just now. Yes, I was approved. I didn’t record what my Chex stats were at the time but I was denied several times online before opening in branch.

Eric
Eric (@guest_1692704)
September 13, 2023 13:39

Christopher Robin,

You seem to apply to a lot of accounts like I do so I might be better off trying in-branch. Are you using Fidelity as your DD like Bill or something else?

Christopher Robin
Christopher Robin (@guest_1692757)
September 13, 2023 14:26

Eric Yes, I tend to average at least 2 Chex hits per month. I am using a real DD.

Eric
Eric (@guest_1693862)
September 14, 2023 14:51

Bill,

Fidelity is still working fine for you, correct?

Gadget - Bank Bonus Geek 🔗
Gadget - Bank Bonus Geek 🔗 (@guest_1640568)
June 23, 2023 16:50

P2 got a letter today with the adverse action, LOL, over a year later…

I think they just added the below additional info.

Chex Score 655

Key factors:
– Asset ownership history
– Recent unique FI DDA inquiry history
– Non-derogatory public record history
– Property ownership history

Brian C 🐕
Brian C 🐕 (@guest_833891)
November 1, 2019 13:21

DP:
P2 applied, clean chex, only 1 entry from 2017. DECLINED.

Patrick
Patrick (@guest_825054)
October 14, 2019 14:59

Is the bonus churnable?