Because manufactured spending is an empirical and local process, incorrect information often pops up about certain methods. Though American Express is selling its prepaid portfolio to Incomm, likely in the next quarter, I’d like to correct some widespread misinformation about the rules for loading Serve cards at Family Dollar (FD)/Dollar General (DG), and discuss a recent change in my area that caused me a bit of headache!
Keep in mind that rules may differ by locality, though I have no reason to believe that is the case here.
Mechanics: A Curiosity
This has nothing to do with the rules of loading, but the mechanics of loading at FD/DG is a logical starting point because it contains some information that will be useful later.
At both FD and DG, the cashier initiates the Serve load process by scanning a barcode located on the back of a small yellow card. The transaction screen will then briefly pop up “Vanilla Reload Network”.
At FD, proceeding with the load requires supervisor permissions. You swipe your Serve card at the POS terminal, the cashier enters the load amount, and you use a debit card at the POS terminal to load.
At DG, the cashier enters the load amount, swipes your Serve card on their keyboard, and you use a debit card at the POS terminal to load.
The Rules
Let us define a transaction as the initiation of the Serve load process by the cashier through the completion of your payment.
You can load up to $500 in a single transaction. (This is a commonly quoted limit online, and I have never attempted to exceed it by splitting payment.)
Many articles and posts state there is a $500 limit to the amount anyone can load at a given FD location (sometimes it is left ambiguous whether it is FD and DG or just FD), with the first person to visit the store that day being the lucky one who can load their card.
While this may vary by area, neither FD nor DG have limits on the number of times you or anyone can load at one store. I have personally loaded $500 three separate times at an FD in a day, and often load $500 twice in consecutive transactions at FD & DG. Other people I’ve spoken to across the country have likewise had success loading more than $500 at one store. Assuming you are at a supervisor’s register, this is much easier at FD because you don’t have to pass your Serve to the cashier to swipe. Being polite and having a good relationship with cashiers is important if you want to load more than once in a row, and loading more than twice in a row has always struck me as far too much.
Other, very variable, rules that you may run into include stores only accepting prepaid debit cards on the InComm network (Vanilla-branded; see below), or stores only accepting cash.
Invalid Merchant
Between the morning and evening of October 30, 2017, the back end for Serve loading at my nearest DG was updated. Poorly. After using a debit card at the POS terminal, the system processed the transaction and took the funds from my debit card before spitting out an invalid merchant error. At this point, the system instructed the cashier that I was entitled to a full refund.
I encountered the same problem at the first (and only) FD I tried, but their system spit out an invalid merchant error as soon as I used a debit card, so no payment was processed.
I could only find a few mentions of an invalid merchant error online, so it appears I am one of the few to run into this. See [1] [2] [3] at Flyertalk. This error can also occur when you’ve hit your monthly load limit.
After some pondering, I went back and tried a Vanilla-branded debit card, which solved my issues. My assumption is that this error ties back to the “Vanilla Reload Network” notification that pops up briefly when starting a Serve load at FD or DG. The system that processes Serve loads, at least at stores in my area, has been updated to enforce the requirement that prepaid cards be on the InComm network in order to be used for Serve loads.
Concluding Thoughts
I hope I’ve clarified some of the misinformation surrounding Serve loads at Family Dollar & Dollar General.
As this is a rather focused (if long) article, I’ve stayed away from other Serve topics. Here’s a quick list of some Serve topics we’ve covered:
- The End of Serve & Bluebird & SoftServe for Manufactured Spend
- Serve Shutdown Wave #6 (with links for more information)
- Six Different Flavors of Serve and How to Remain Fee-Free (Green Serve & One VIP Serve being of interest)
Questions? Comments? Corrections? Please drop them below!
Hello. I have had no issues in the past loading my Serve prepaid card using Visa Gift cards. Today I noticed Dollar General updated their terminals, so that the cashier has no keyboard anymore, and the swiping of my serve card takes place at the terminal in front of me at the counter. When trying to load my Serve card, we couldnt get it load using any debit card. I tried a visa gift card, as well as my wells fargo bank debit card, and neither one was not allowed. unfortunately I dont have the exact error message. I will get that next time.
Is anyone aware of any issue loading Serve cards with a debit card using the new terminals? Or did my casher not understand how to use the terminal? I wouldnt think that functionality would be removed all together. I didnt try to load it with cash, I just went to a store with older terminals and it loaded without issues.
anybody else have that issue?
Does anyone have data points for using any of the *Everywhere (Grocery Everywhere, Fuel Everywhere, etc) VGCs to load Serve @ DG or FD? Thanks.
Partially answering my own question… Grocery Everywhere works at DG.
Is there any reason ppl choose to buy Serve cards in retail stores rather than apply for free online at serve.com (and presumably wait to be sent the card by mail)?
How is the statement date determined, for the Green Serve (free reloads), for example?
Free loads at WM if you purchase there.
Waking the dead a bit… tried to load my GreenServe this morning @ a DG I’d never been to before and was told by the cashier that they could only load via cash–no cards. She checked with the store manager who then confirmed that with me and also said that most DGs will be going to cash-only loads if they haven’t already. I loaded at a different DG just yesterday using a VGC, so I’m wondering if she’s right about other stores.
(I loaded without issue at a FD and a WM a few hours later.)
…and was just given the “cash only” spiel at a different FD from the one I successfully loaded at this morning. Was told that it’s company-wide and stores that allow loading by debit card “aren’t supposed to be.” 🤔
At WM, can you go to the regular cashiers or only to money center?
I wondering the same thing too.
YMMV…there are stores where they tell you to go to Customer Service or MC when loading prepaid cards.
Strictly speaking, any register, but I’m usually directed to the MoneyCenter if I want to do a single load of $500 or more.
I do both. Sometimes I’ll hit a couple different cashiers and the money center in one visit
I tried to load $500 in 3 transactions at the same dollar general onto a VIP serve. The third transaction withdrew the funds and then directed the merchant to put the funds back on the card. I had to call bhnetworks to open up a case in order to unlock the card. I have to upload my receipt to [email protected]
DP: went very smooth at DG to load Green Serve with fixed-value Metabank MCGC, so if there is any block on non-Incomm gift cards it’s very incomplete.
For a Serve beginner, would the following likely work? I’m not looking to MS, just meet MSR with minimal inconvenience/cost.
1. Buy $250 OV MCs at Sam’s Club (get 2% back which covers the $4.88 fee plus get cc points/miles)
2. Go to Family Dollar or Dollar General and buy a Green serve card
3. Ask them to load $500 on my serve card
4. Swipe two cards from step 1. Repeat with another 2 cards on the same green serve card if needed.
5. Use the $500/$1000 to pay off a portion of my credit card bill before the end of the month to avoid the Serve monthly fee.
If I’m understanding this correctly, when used in moderation this is a simple/quick and I’d incur no fees except the initial purchase of the green card (which has a $15 bonus if purchased from dollar general by 2/14 per the most recent DoC post about Serve).
I gather that CVS does not work, and Walmart is YMMV. I also read that you should say they are debit cards if asked and some went as far as to say to show a bank card if they need to see it but I’d rather feign ignorance that it says debit on it than directly lie to someone by switching cards.
What is “OV”?
Why are you only paying off a portion of your credit card bill?
Don’t you need to transfer the money from Serve to a bank before you can pay off your credit card bill or can you pay your credit card directly from Serve?
One vanilla.
Because he’ll pay with rest with autopay.
No, yes.
Presumably there is more spend on the card than has been loaded to Serve. I would recommend you read the MS threads if you want to learn more.
I’ve read everything. Thanks nonetheless.
If you’ve read the theads here check out reddit churning and flyertalk. Lots more info there.
FYI that is certainly MS. I would start with one swipe on one card at first. Start slowly. Definitely refer to them as debits.
Thanks – agree, I’ll probably only try it if I’m concerned about not hitting a MSR. Worst case scenario I’ll have a handful of gift cards and burn through them gradually or use them to pay taxes and still come out slightly ahead.
FYI to those who bought GCs and are unable to drain them immediately, know that ALL of these GCs can be hacked at any time. There is a case on FT who has $100 vanilla GC she apparently kept in a safe box and when she tried to use it months later, balance was used for a UA flight and she wanted to know how to get her funds back. OP was probably unaware that funds can be stolen even w/o physical card on hand, cards can be used online as long as one has the card#, exp date and CVV.
So it is best to drain these VGCs ASAP no later than 48 hrs after purchase.
Good to note – I dumped two of my gift cards for $2 a piece on estimated taxes a couple weeks ago for that reason. Not the most efficient, but still breaks even and eliminates any remaining risk.
It used to be possible to do three or more loads at a Dollar General in one shot (I would use multiple Serve cards). But Dollar General has apparently instituted an anti-fraud velocity limit of 1K. On the same day, at two different DGs, my first two $500 loads with OVs were executed without incident, as usual. The third $500 load at both stores, however, went awry. After the store manager got involved each time, those third $500 transactions were apparently aborted. But after nine days the $500 hasn’t posted back to either card (DG accounting says the transactions didn’t go through), so I will have to play PITA games with Incomm to work to get my money back.
A quick question for all the pros,I know One VIP does not charge monthly fee if you have 0 balance before your statement date, even you did not load $500 that month, what about the green serve, do they charge you 4.95$ monthly even you have a 0 balance? I just got one and do not plan to keep it open if charge monthly fee? Any one knows?
No if the balance is zero, no fee is assessed,
Thanks Dan.
Just received an email today… Amex Serve One VIP no longer accepting applications eff. 1-1-2018!
“but as a current ONE VIP Cardholder, we want to let you know that there will be no impact to your Serve Account”
Get them now while you can… I’ve heard people suggest applying and keeping some unactivated.
I wonder if you can still activate post-1/1/18…
Yes I just received this same exact email today as well. I also have the One VIP Serve.
A little late on getting to this…..but I’m curious about all the recent chatter on Serve cards. If you had one but it got closed you can’t get another one even though Amex doesn’t ‘own’ them?