Subscribe
Notify of
guest

17 Comments
newest
oldest most voted

John
John (@guest_2025572)
March 18, 2025 15:00

Damn, already did the $20M E-Trade deal. This seems better.

Amanda
Amanda (@guest_2025565)
March 18, 2025 14:56

I read this as an OR with the accounts – does anyone know what if I open both a taxable brokerage AND a retirement account – would the balance on the total of the accounts be eligible for the 1% bonus match. I was going to call and ask but thought I would check here first. I just want to decide which account I should move or if I can do both for an even greater bonus.

Jay
Jay (@guest_2025579)
March 18, 2025 15:12

Each individually are eligible. So $20K min for both. Bogleheads is discussing it and someone asked SoFi reps about multiple accounts.

Demitri
Demitri (@guest_2025539)
March 18, 2025 14:36

Can the funds stay invested during the ACAT transfer if coming from Fidelity? Considering moving a Roth IRA from Fidelity to SoFi

Brian
Brian (@guest_2025545)
March 18, 2025 14:40

Yes

Jay
Jay (@guest_2025578)
March 18, 2025 15:12

That’s how ACATS works.

tim bergland
tim bergland (@guest_2025506)
March 18, 2025 13:49

I’ve avoided these transfer offers over the past decade because I’m concerned about hiccups in the ACATS process. Is is relatively straightforward?

John
John (@guest_2025577)
March 18, 2025 15:09

If by these you mean specifically apex brokers, I’m totally with you.

I don’t want my tax lots messed up either. I’m sticking to major brokerages, like E-Trade, Merrill Edge, Schwab, etc. and so far years and many bonuses later not a single screwup.

I’m totally not interested in saving my records (because brokerage screwed up cost basis) for when many years down the line I eventually sell my VTI, VOO holdings. Although obviously I do have records, but they are just in spreadsheet. Not interested in going over that if I get audited.

Jay
Jay (@guest_2025407)
March 18, 2025 12:19

SoFi is Apex Clearing for custody/clearing. Usual potential for tax issues apply. Save a copy of your tax lots before ACATS in!

Brian
Brian (@guest_2025378)
March 18, 2025 11:45

“It’s the golden age for brokerage bonuses as better and better offers continue to roll out from various financial institutions.” 

This right here is why you don’t do the 2% Robinhood 5-year lock. Churn, baby, churn!

Might be transferring $100k from US Bank if Smartly gets nerfed.

Howard
Howard (@guest_2025413)
March 18, 2025 12:24

Only if they would payout now and claw back if withdraw before next year. Having to wait 9 months for the bonus is off putting.

Terry
Terry (@guest_2025352)
March 18, 2025 11:26

how does this compare with Webull? Webull’s offer is more, right (for all tiers up to 500k-1m)

Jay
Jay (@guest_2025418)
March 18, 2025 12:29

WeBull is better on some of the low ends of their tiers. SoFi is a flat 1%, so you can do the math to compare… Timelines are a different as far as hold period and when cash is paid. SoFi is 9mo hold, with delayed cash payout in Jan 2026.

JD
JD (@guest_2025419)
March 18, 2025 12:29

Not necessarily, it depends on how much you want to transfer. In every tier there’s a crossover point after which Sofi is better since it’s payout is a ramp vs. Webull’s staircase.

Penny
Penny (@guest_2025344)
March 18, 2025 11:21

I am wondering if acat 20k cash from fidelity over to sofi would work. I can’t tell from the terms. Wondering if asset means stocks/etf/mutual fund only or cash is considered

Howard
Howard (@guest_2025359)
March 18, 2025 11:33

I’m not sure but I’d guess cash would count as well. The thing is you won’t know until January 2026. You can always just load up on SGOV and then transfer.